Probate, Inheritance Tax and Capital Gains Tax – Some Issues to Consider
Probate, Inheritance Tax and Capital Gains Tax – Some Issues to Consider
If you already own a property as your main residence and the value of the estate (with its property) you are inheriting is over £1m, in most cases you will want the value of the inherited property for probate purposes to be low as this will mean the total of the inheritance tax (IHT) and capital gains tax (CGT) you have to pay will also be lower. This is because CGT is taxed at a lower rate than IHT.
I have reading up a bit on probate valuations recently for a client – and how the taxation system interacts with this.
I could not advise the lady too much as I am not a tax advisor, but I was able to give her a general indication.
At death, the government, in the form of the HMRC, want their pound of flesh in tax.
They can get this in two ways – inheritance tax (IHT), if that is due on the estate – and later when and if it comes to be sold in the lifetime of the beneficiary – through capital gains tax (CGT), assuming the property is a second home and does not become the main primary residence of the beneficiary.
In this example, I am going to assume the beneficiary already has another property he owns, so the property being inherited becomes liable to CGT – as do most second properties, whether they are let or left empty or just used by the beneficiary for occasional use.
What sort of probate value on the property being inherited is desirable – high or low?
If an estate is not going to be subject to inheritance tax but the property being inherited is to be sold at some point, then the beneficiaries might like to see a higher probate valuation, because this probate value also sets the base acquisition cost on which CGT will be charged later. The higher the probate/ base acquisition cost, the lower the capital gain will be when it comes to being sold. To repeat: This is because the probate valuation of the property, then becomes the base acquisition cost for the property.
If the estate is going to be subject to inheritance tax and is to be sold at some point, then the beneficiaries might like to hope that the probate valuation comes out lower. The simple reason is because CGT is charged at a lower rate than IHT.
The key point to note always, is that one does not have to pay CGT on gains which have already been taxed for IHT. In other words, you don’t have to pay tax twice on the same gain, under any circumstances.
To repeat, the probate value once agreed on, for IHT purposes, becomes, in effect, the base acquisition cost for capital gains purposes.
So, let’s look at the case where the estate is going to be subject to inheritance tax.
In this case, if the beneficiaries were to sell the property for more than the probate value, (which is usually the case simply due to property inflation), they only pay CGT on the difference between the sale price, (after deductions of all selling costs) and the probate value/acquisition cost.
Very simply, IHT is levied at 40% for any estate value over £1m (in the case where two parents have died, leaving their estate to their children), as opposed to capital gains tax, which, of course, for most taxpayers, is levied at a much lower rate – 24% – so, this amounts to a saving of at least £160.00 on each £1,000 less of probate value.
I say “at least” because:
- Given that one is only required to pay capital gains tax within 60 days after sale of an asset – and that any sale is, of course, by definition, some way off in the future – this allows for an “imputed interest” to be earned on any “saving” in the interim.
- The costs of selling – estate agent fees and all legal fees – can also be deducted from any sale cost before capital gains are calculated.
- Everyone has a personal capital gains tax allowance – £3K – that applies to each beneficiary of the property.
So, fairly obviously, in this case, the beneficiaries want the probate valuation as low as possible – as long as such valuation is sensible and supportable of course.
Estate agents doing probate valuations must be able to defend their valuations, in the unlikely event they are queries by HMRC, which will be followed up by the local District Valuer.
Valuations submitted as part of the probate process must be supportable by refence to “reasonably comparable” sales and other information relevant at the date of the death.
Queries on valuations from District Surveyors are very rare but can happen.
In the very unlikely event that a challenge is made and sustained, the executors may be asked to pay more IHT, but should that happen, the base acquisition cost for capital gains tax would then be the new, revised probate value.
The HMRC guidance on this is clear: that you ideally get at least 3 estate agency valuations and take the average of them. If that is done and they are shown to be made in good faith, there should not be any issues.
Doing a F*****
However, some estate agents are known to do what is widely known in the estate agency trade in London as “doing a F**** number”, (insert name of very aggressive London agent here).
This means they value very high, so the vendor is gulled into thinking they can achieve such a value when they come to sell – and so that the agent gets the inevitable instruction for sale further down the line.
Later, they are forced to reduce the unrealistic price, but by then they have the instruction and are the incumbent agent. Typically, agents employing such an approach will request a long period for the sole sale instruction, so they cannot be kicked off the job when no sale arises at their inflated price.
Unfortunately, such a practice means such agents value high and over the market value, even when they are supposed to be giving fair market value for probate purposes.
Around 60% of estate agents charge to do a probate valuation – typical costs in the south of England are £180 in outer London and the southeast of England for a three-bedroom property. So, if you end up paying for all three agents, that is a cool £540.
Another alternative is to not go on the estate agency route for probate valuations at all, but instead just go for what is known as the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) Red Book Valuation.
These carry more weight in the event of an HMRC query and will also cost you around £500 to £600 in outer London and the southeast of England for a three-bedroom property.
RICS Red Book probate valuations also tend to be more conservative (i.e. lower) and possibly more realistic in their assessment of what the real value of a property is and what someone would really pay for the property. Obviously, as the RICS surveyor won’t be ever selling the property and earning a fee for doing that, there is no risk of them “gulling” the executors/ beneficiaries with a high and ludicrous valuation in an attempt to con executors/ beneficiaries into giving them the sale instruction, when that time comes.
I have taken the trouble to illustrate the interactions between IHT and CGT for a case by way of two worked examples below.
Worked examples
I have set out two examples.
Both cases assume £500K “other assets”.
In case A, the probate value for the house is £725K, in case B it is £825K.
In this simple case, both husband and wife had died, the husband died first and gave everything to his wife and when she died all the assets went to their child. As explained before, IHT is payable on any estate with total value over £1m, where the deceased owns a property and has children and the total estate assets are under £2m. In this case no lifetime gifts were made. (This case is, of course, a simplification, but it works to demonstrate the principle).
Both cases shown here assume selling the house in the future at say £1m.
Both cases assume estate agency fees of 1.25% plus VAT = £12K and total conveyancing and other allowable selling fees for CGT purposes of £2K, so a total of £14K is the allowable deductible selling costs for capital gains tax.
As you will see, in case B, the higher probate value, (825K compared to £725K in case A), results in an extra £16K of total tax to pay.
Case A; Probate value 725K
IHT calculation:
£725K plus 500K, so total value of estate is £1225K, so 225K subject to IHT at 40% = £90K to pay.
CGT calculation:
£1m sale cost less £725K (probate/acquisition cost) = £275, less £14K allowable selling costs = £261K. Taxable at 24% = £62.6K, less £6K CGT allowance = £56.6K.
Total tax due: 90K plus 56.6K = £146.6K
Case B; Probate value 825K
IHT calculation:
£825K plus 500K, so total value of estate is £1325K, so 325K subject to IHT at 40% = £130K to pay.
CGT calculation:
£1m sale cost less £825K (probate/acquisition cost) = £175K, less £14K allowable selling costs = £161K. Taxable at 24% = £38.6K to pay, less £6K CGT allowance = £32.6K.
Total tax due: 130K plus 32.6K = £162.6K
Note: Obviously, the higher the probate value, the even higher the difference in tax to pay – at least £160 for every £1,000 higher probate value, reflecting the difference in IHT and CGT rates. (In fact, this is an underestimate as it takes no account of the extra interest that would be earned on monies, in the case of a lower probate value).
Services for Private Landlords and Organisations
We help landlords and property investors by showing them how to make money in the private rented sector using ways which are fair to tenants and which involve minimal risk. Our advice is completely independent.
We also advise a range of organisations too – public, charities and private – to help them develop and improve their services and products for private landlords.
HOME PAGE : Home – Letting Focus
For general information on our CONSULTING SERVICES: Consultancy and Seminars
For ONE-TO-ONE PRIVATE CONSULTANCY FOR PRIVATE LANDLORDS: Property Advice
IN THE MEDIA: Recent Press Coverage
BOOKS:
“SUCCESSFUL PROPERTY LETTING”:
Click here to Find Out More and Buy it. And if you are from an organisation and would like to bulk buy, please ask us for special rates.
“BUY TO LET LANDLORDS GUIDE TO FINDING GREAT TENANTS”:
Also, get this, which covers everything you’ll ever need to know to avoid either you or your letting agent getting anyone other than the perfect tenant. Click Here to Buy It.
BOOK FOR TENANTS:
Kids going off and renting for the first time? My Book for Tenants is also Available
TO JOIN OUR FREE NEWSLETTER MAILER which goes to over 3,960 people (as at December 2023) just send an email to david@LettingFocus.com
We do not send spam or sell our mailing list to advertisers, though we occasionally mail landlords about good products from third parties. Please put us on your “white-list” to ensure you receive our emails.
OFFERS ON PRODUCTS FOR LANDLORDS and TO ADVERTISE YOUR PRODUCTS to LANDLORDS: Landlords Resources
TWITTER PAGE Twitter has banned me twice permanently for life. (I was unbanned permanently once, I may be the only person that has ever happened to!?). The ban is for having “Wrong Thoughts” and “Provoking Quarrels” mainly about coercive Convid injections, “vaccine” mandates and house arrest policies, but they may relent and put me back live again, one of these days and when I can be bothered to appeal: Twitter
This taxes are higher and higher.
Yes, everywhere you look they are higher.