Clueless Local Authority and my Kafkaesque Experience in Lewisham
This is a tale of my experience of public sector incompetence that has been going on for an incredible fourteen years.
I own a maisonette in a two storied development in Lewisham. I have had it for many years. The property is a leasehold flat. The freeholder is the local authority – Lewisham – though for many years an “arm’s length management organisation” called Lewisham Homes ran it for the council.
Lewisham are responsible for the estate where the flat sits, for looking after and maintaining the grounds, the car park and for fixing the exterior fabric of the building. I would give them a four out of ten for most functions but only 2 out of ten for looking after the buildings and doing works to maintain the buildings properly. I would say the costs are reasonable, but the standard of their work is not so great, so one gets what one pays for, I guess.
Things have improved very slightly since when the estate was under the arm’s length management of Lewisham Homes, but only very slightly. Calls get answered quicker, but that is about it. Under Lewisham Homes, who were charged with looking after the council’s housing stock, it just seemed to be just another layer of management in the way – and a very handsomely paid one at that. I saw what the directors earned.
Lewisham Homes was broken up about four years ago and the running of the council’s housing estate was bought back in house. But improvements have been barely visible other than slightly fast call handling though there are the usual multiple menu options of course and the obligatory disclaimer, “We are experiencing high call volumes right now but your call is important to us”.
Fourteen years ago, I first noticed that the roof of my flat (on the top first floor) was being touched by a branch from an overhanging tree whose trunk is growing in a garden which is the other side of a wall, this garden being owned by a children’s nursery.
I would guess the branch is about 15 cm across and the height of the branch is about 6 meters high. The branch is so long that it cuts across a communal pathway which is accessed by any resident on the estate to reach the communal garden before resting on the roof of my flat, which is adjacent to the communal garden.
As the estates’ manager is Lewisham Homes/ Lewisham and because I as a leaseholder have no right to carry out maintenance and cut back trees, I contacted Lewisham Homes to get the tree branch cut back.
You would think that would be a simple job – perhaps taking a decent tree surgeon all of five to fifteen minutes.
But Oh No!
So, what has happened is a bizarre Kafkaesque situation develops that has gone on for all those years.
The people responsible for the grounds of the estate where my flat sits in Lewisham say they cannot do it “because it is the trees department who are responsible for the trees on housing estate managed by Lewisham Council as our team do not have equipment to trim back trees” so instead I must submit a form at Lewisham’s website to the Tree Department of the council. This I then do, on an online form, for which you get a reference number back.
This being a local authority, not a private company, their service levels place the onus on you to keep coming back to check if there has been an update. (I think the idea of this “non-service” is that people forget about it, lose the case number or otherwise go away for some other reason).
Eventually, after around eight weeks, the Tree Department updates to say, “No Action – Private land”.
Of course, this is nonsense because the branch is not on private land, it is overhanging land for which Lewisham as freeholder and estates manager under the terms of the lease is responsible, a fact they have already admitted – both the communal passageway land to the garden used by all residents as well as the roof of my flat.
By the way, if you don’t like a reply you get on the Lewisham system, you cannot write a reply to their response, you have to instead open another case, referring to the first case – and again wait another eight weeks for their system to update with a response to that, which will inevitably repeat what you were told previously, as their staff seem incapable of following the thread to the original case.
This odd system means that the first case is closed and thus seems to act in the same way as complaints were dealt with by Lewisham Homes. In this way, Lewisham Homes, when they were the gaffers achieved a 90% or so “complaints resolution score”, an achievement they loudly trumpeted in every newsletter. All they were doing is simply closing a case before it was resolved! Their complaint handling was always appalling.
I am not sure if since the demise of Lewisham Homes and with Lewisham Council now directly managing the estate, if this is also how they deal with complaints. I suspect it is. Readers – do let me know if you know.
Lewisham think that I should cut the branch down. I keep pointing out to them that I can’t because the land over which the tree branch hangs is not my land, it is theirs, which means both me and any tree surgeon that I hire would not be insured or covered if, during the removal, someone walking underneath was hurt by a falling branch.
Lewisham have also suggested that I contact the owner of the nursery and get them to cut the branch down. I tried this once, but they were not interested and anyway, to do this properly they would need to gain access to Lewisham’s land to do it, for which they are not insured and do not have the owners (in this case Lewisham’s) permission.
And so, this situation has been going on for fourteen years now.
I sometimes wonder if anyone is even in Lewisham’s Tree Department. I have another property where they simply tag “Private Land” on any tree cut back request for that property too – and in this case the offending tree trunk is even in a plant bed that Lewisham manages. I seriously think this Tree Department could be a ghost department. No one really works there.
It also seems they don’t understand the law and that an owner of a tree that has branches that go over a third party’s land has no right or obligation to cut them back. The third party, can, of course, cut back the offending branches, but that is a different matter.
On recent calls (including in the latest laughable one today) and in writing to Lewisham I have said this – see below. Next week I will copy this blog post to Lewisham’s CEO, just so it is even more on the record.
Any damage and costs arising to my leasehold property caused by Lewisham’s failure to remove the branch under the terms of the lease – the lease which sets out Lewisham’s responsibility to properly manage their XXXXXX Close estate grounds and to keep the grounds safe (and the leasehold properties safe from damage) – will be charged to Lewisham. Also, Lewisham should be aware that the overhanging branch is a hazard to members of the XXXXX Close community who live in the Close and pay rent or service charges to Lewisham and have rights to access the passageway to the communal garden and that I have hereby advised Lewisham of that fact and they have again chosen to do nothing about it.
Finally, please do let me know of any other similar incompetence at councils that you have experienced. Fill in the comment box under the bylines. Oh, and do you also find, these days, when dealing with the call centres of large amorphous large corporations and public bodies, that these days they increasingly don’t listen and are the first to get aggressive, and then call you out for being aggressive when you are trying to make a point that they refuse to listen to or when they keep talking over you? Another modern phenomenon.
Services for Private Landlords and Organisations
We help landlords and property investors by showing them how to make money in the private rented sector using ways which are fair to tenants and which involve minimal risk. Our advice is completely independent.
We also advise a range of organisations too – public, charities and private – to help them develop and improve their services and products for private landlords.
HOME PAGE : Home – Letting Focus
For general information on our CONSULTING SERVICES: Consultancy and Seminars
For ONE-TO-ONE PRIVATE CONSULTANCY FOR PRIVATE LANDLORDS: Property Advice
IN THE MEDIA: Recent Press Coverage
BOOKS:
“SUCCESSFUL PROPERTY LETTING”:
Click here to Find Out More and Buy it. And if you are from an organisation and would like to bulk buy, please ask us for special rates.
“BUY TO LET LANDLORDS GUIDE TO FINDING GREAT TENANTS”:
Also, get this, which covers everything you’ll ever need to know to avoid either you or your letting agent getting anyone other than the perfect tenant. Click Here to Buy It.
BOOK FOR TENANTS:
Kids going off and renting for the first time? My Book for Tenants is also Available
TO JOIN OUR FREE NEWSLETTER MAILER which goes to over 3,960 people (as at December 2023) just send an email to david@LettingFocus.com
We do not send spam or sell our mailing list to advertisers, though we occasionally mail landlords about good products from third parties. Please put us on your “white-list” to ensure you receive our emails.
OFFERS ON PRODUCTS FOR LANDLORDS and TO ADVERTISE YOUR PRODUCTS to LANDLORDS: Landlords Resources
TWITTER PAGE Twitter banned me twice permanently for life. (I may be the only person that has ever happened to!?). After three years and two months, I finally got round to appealing again, hoping the new ownership would allow me back on. They did! So, I am back on and so are my 7,000 plus followers : Twitter
As a Yank friend of yours commenting from the US, I must say that your situation is even more bizarre than those the we find ourselves here when dealing with government entities. Insanity indeed
I sometimes think that one could remove half the workforces in the public sector and put in 5% of new bods from the private sector as managers at different levels – and productivity would rise by a least a third.
Hi David,
Yes I agree that the Council should have acted to cut back the tree to make it safe. Take pictures this will help prove that they have failed in their” duty of care” and been negligent should anything happen despite you contacting them.
Having large overhanging branches on a flat roof with all the leaves will also not be doing the felt much good. Does the tree have a TPO on it?
Any works carried out would need the agreement of the nursery so maybe you should seek their permission and armed with that go back to the Council. From My limited understanding, i thought that overhanging branches that cross boundaries can be cut back and cuttings returned to the neighbouring property where practical. You certainly don’t want them overhanging buildings which may cause a safety issue.
I would also copy in your local MP and contact your Local Head councillor.
Thanks v much Dominic,
Yes, I should contact local MP and Councillor, maybe will copy them in to letter I send to the leader of Lewisham Council.
The permission of the nursery is NOT required.
If branches overhang then you are entitled to cut them back to the boundary.
Simples.
Thank you. I know this, but I cannot do it as leaseholder as I have no authority nor insurance to get up on a ladder myself or hire a tree surgeon to cut back on the communal grounds that Lewisham are supposed to be responsible for.
As this has not progressed, I would put Lewisham council on notice that if there is any damage to the property they will be held responsible for any repairs that need to take place or for that matter if anybody gets injured they will be responsible due to their complete failure to act and negligence.
Thanks Dominic,
Yes, I have done that now.
It is quite ridiculous. Public sector incompetence.