A Mass Closing of Migrant Hotels would have led to Increasing Rents in the Private Rented Sector.

The closing of migrant hotels would have led to increasing rents in the private rented sector. This looked a certainty, yet few in the media have cottoned on to it yet.

Closing Migrant Hotels

For a few weeks it looked like it may have to move all migrants / “asylum seekers” / economic migrants, (choose your own label!), out of hotels. No wonder it threw everything at its legal challenge to the Epping Hotel ruling.

But few people in the media seemed to be asking: What next? Where will they all go?

Serco are one of the companies who manage the hotels for the government, raking in much moolah over many years. But they have also long been involved in another scheme: housing asylum seekers for the government via 3- or 5-year lease schemes with residential landlords in the private rented sector.  Approximately, 38,000 asylum seekers are currently in hotels and 66,000 are in “dispersed accommodation”, (mainly the private rented sector), with around half of them housed by Serco.

Under these long lease schemes, the landlord gets paid a guaranteed rent for the entire length of the lease, (typically 3 or 5 years), with most repairs being carried out by a company such as Serco itself or one of its affiliates or subsidiary companies. The private landlord gets paid the agreed fixed rent whether the property is occupied or not, for the entire term of the lease.

Serco and others have been running these long lease schemes for at least three decades and have been doing very well out of them too. The other companies involved are Mears (in Scotland, NI and the north of England), Clearspring (in Wales and the south of England), whilst Serco are mainly operating in the English midlands and the north west of England.

The costs of accommodating in the private rented sector are thought to be around 10% of what accommodating in hotels costs, so you can see the attraction to the government. However, accommodating in dispersed accommodation does spread a potential problem far and wide across communities where problems are harder to control.

Basically, it is easy money for Serco at al. it is paid straight from the government, i.e., the taxpayer (er, also known as you and me). The risks to Serco et al are very low. There is, after all, not much that can go wrong – all they need to do is quantify the future repairs obligation, which is hardly difficult, as any half- decent landlord will tell you. And the private landlords are happy too – they get a guaranteed rent for the term of the lease and someone else, such as Serco, worries about the repairs and maintenance and dealing with tenant issues.

What people (and the media) often fail to appreciate is that council and housing associations also offer similar 3- and 5-year lease schemes with guaranteed rent and help with repairs. But these schemes, whilst identical to the ones for migrants, are for homeless local people – and usually for people who are not “asylum seekers”. These schemes – for the “local homeless” – if you wish to call them that, have also been running for decades. (This may include, of course, people whose asylum claims have been upheld).

For a private landlord, long lease schemes where a guaranteed rent is paid for 3 or 5 years, with repairs included are obviously more attractive than renting direct to someone who is dependent on housing and other benefits, even if the payments under the lease schemes are a little lower than the landlord might get for renting direct to a tenant.

Renting direct to a tenant who is on benefits, (or anyone else for that matter), means that if the tenant goes into arrears, under the current stupid anti-landlord laws and failing court system, it will be at least 9 to 12 months until they can be removed, (if they decide to stay put and ignore all court orders). This is all thanks to successive governments ridiculous policies, (e.g. you cannot start proceedings until the tenants are three months in arrears), and a court system that is slow, cumbersome, crumbling and frankly useless for landlords.

So, think about it – a risk of possible 9 to 12 months with no rent vs guaranteed rent underwritten by the taxpayer. Der, not exactly a hard decision for a landlord to make, is it?

Another thing most people don’t know is that Serco et al, have historically paid higher rents to private landlords to house asylum seekers than the local authorities and the housing associations can pay under their lease schemes for the “homegrown local homeless”.

With the possible closing of the so-called asylum hotels, (or at least just some of them, now that the government has stopped the Epping hotel closure), everyone involved in housing at local government level remains in great fear about what could happen next. For years they have had to put up with the likes of Serco coming into their areas and taking away housing stock for asylum seekers that most (though not all) council workers would prefer was used for the local homeless people.

But the closing of the migrant hotels could have hugely increased the scale of this and could have meant a huge crowding out of local homeless people.

Of course, few in local government will speak up about any of this for fear of being branded “faaargh right” or worse.

If all the migrant hotels did ever shut, the numbers who will need to be accommodated in the private rented sectors’ HMOs will rise drastically.  

Should it happen, many landlords who hold existing leases to house local homeless people, could, once their leases end, increasingly move across to house asylum seekers instead because the payments being offered are that much higher.

And it could have been much, much worse. And here’s why: In the short term, I expected to see a lot of existing houses in multiple occupation (HMOs) which are not currently on lease schemes, but which are housing local people being moved straight over to long lease schemes for asylum seekers, with the current occupants being given notice to vacate.

Renters Rights Bill Seems Strangely Stuck

Perhaps that is why the Renters Rights Bill seems to be strangely stuck at its final hurdles – because once it is law, a landlord cannot repossess other than in a few limited circumstances, such as wishing to sell the property or move in himself.

Maybe this explains the odd delay in it becoming law: i.e. the government thought it might need a few months to move people from hotels to private rented accommodation. Obviously, the government cannot achieve their goals if the landlords cannot evict the current occupants.   

HMOs are hard work, and a lot of the work that private landlords must do is in managing the occupants. So, when Serco et al really get going and offer long-term guaranteed rent schemes lease schemes for the HMO type accommodation for migrants who were formerly in “migrant hotels”, we really could see large scale evictions of current occupants.

Private landlords with HMOs will get a guaranteed rent for years with none of the repairing obligations and will be able to pass on the considerable aggravation of managing the occupants to the likes of Serco. What is not to like from their point of view?

Some Landlords Will Say No

It could be that many private landlords will just refuse to give over their properties. I see on a few forums that the view of many landlords is to tell the government to “get stuffed”.

In part, this feeling of not wanting to help the government get out of a hole and help solve their migrant dilemma reflects what many see as years of attacks on their lettings business via new and higher taxes and ever increased regulation. It is payback time.

Other landlords will not want to do it for ethical reasons – reasoning that most of the migrants are not genuine asylum seekers and are just economic migrants coming to “soft touch UK”. They might prefer to accommodate local homeless people and those on benefits instead, even if the returns are lower and the risks are higher.

But many landlords will be swayed – and if they are, this will make HMO accommodation harder to find, and it will push up rents sharply in HMOs and to a lesser extent in other private rented accommodation. Many students live in HMOs as do young professionals, both could see accommodation much harder to find and more expensive too in the future.

Some landlords at the forums have pointed out that lots of mortgage lenders do not allow private landlords to let under long lease schemes – and many insurers do not like them either. I wonder if the government has thought about that. Probably not!

Finally, there are many on what I believe is now called the “faaargh right” who claim that the migrants in the hotels have a higher rate of offending, especially in relation to sex related crimes. If this is so, it is one thing to police the migrants in the hotels and the protests around them, but good luck dealing with local anger over criminal activities of migrants in HMOs scattered all across the land.

Anger is already high, things could get much, much worse. But maybe that is the intention as unrest and civil disorder gives government an excuse to clamp down and further reduce free speech and impose more control and more surveillance?

I see they are already banging on about ID cards yet again, as a way to control migration.

Er, no it won’t. And no doubt the dear Tony Blair is much to the fore behind the scenes on this.

STOP PRESS! After I wrote this, I started getting word that our esteemed Chancellor, Rach from Accounts is now seriously mulling making landlords pay National Insurance on rents. As a good friend of mine who has 100 buy to lets in Lancashire just said, “Well, that’s ten per cent straight onto the rents then”. Quite! We are truly governed by clowns.

Services for Private Landlords and Organisations

We help landlords and property investors by showing them how to make money in the private rented sector using ways which are fair to tenants and which involve minimal risk. Our advice is completely independent.

We also advise a range of organisations too – public, charities and private – to help them develop and improve their services and products for private landlords.

HOME PAGE : Home – Letting Focus

For general information on our CONSULTING SERVICES: Consultancy and Seminars

For ONE-TO-ONE PRIVATE CONSULTANCY FOR PRIVATE LANDLORDS: Property Advice

IN THE MEDIA: Recent Press Coverage

BOOKS:

“SUCCESSFUL PROPERTY LETTING”:

Click here to Find Out More and Buy it. And if you are from an organisation and would like to bulk buy, please ask us for special rates.

“BUY TO LET LANDLORDS GUIDE TO FINDING GREAT TENANTS”:

Also, get this, which covers everything you’ll ever need to know to avoid either you or your letting agent getting anyone other than the perfect tenant. Click Here to Buy It.

BOOK FOR TENANTS:

Kids going off and renting for the first time? My Book for Tenants is also Available

TO JOIN OUR FREE NEWSLETTER MAILER which goes to over 3,960 people (as at December 2023) just send an email to david@LettingFocus.com

We do not send spam or sell our mailing list to advertisers, though we occasionally mail landlords about good products from third parties. Please put us on your “white-list” to ensure you receive our emails.

OFFERS ON PRODUCTS FOR LANDLORDS and TO ADVERTISE YOUR PRODUCTS to LANDLORDS: Landlords Resources

TWITTER / X:

Twitter banned me twice permanently for life. (I may be the only person that has ever happened to!?). After three years and two months, I finally got round to appealing again, hoping the new ownership would allow me back on. They did! So, I am back on and so are my 7,000 plus followers : Twitter 

7 comments

  • Excellent article that should be in the mainstream as it warns of the unfolding catastrophe and consequences that uncontrolled immigration is edging us towards. The “dots” have always been there but no one has joined them so well as Mr Lawrenson. Govt’s are inept and continue to fail to see the unintended consequences of their failure to include trade-offs and incentives when making policy. But as you conclude, the whole debacle could be part of a grander plan to control and surveil us as we continue “on the road to serfdom”!

  • Very interesting article as a Yank watching from afar. Gives detailed insight into the corner which the UK government has painted itself into? Excellent information

  • Something I’m not understanding here, when you say “No wonder it threw everything at its legal challenge to the Epping Hotel ruling.”, do you mean the government?

    Because later you say “The costs of accommodating in the private rented sector are thought to be around 10% of what accommodating in hotels costs, so you can see the attraction to the government.”

    Thus wouldn’t the government welcome not using the hotels of it’s cheaper in the private rented sector and therefore why challenge it?

    I’m obviously missing something here, genuine question, cheers!

    • Good comment, and thanks for that and I have slightly amended the piece now. The thing is, yes the costs are cheaper in an HMO than in a hotel but the big downside is that it involves HMO landlords getting rid of current occupants in favour of those who have been in the “migrant hotels”, which looks bad. Plus, also it is arguably easier to police a hotel in one place than a distributed “problem”.

  • Great, thanks for the update and clarification.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.