Making Tax Digital – More Like Making Tax Deliberately Hard

“The most insanely mad tax idea ever.” That’s how one exasperated commentator on Accounting Web described HMRC’s staggeringly expensive plan to force millions into submitting four “mini tax returns” a year on top of the existing full year tax return.

It was all announced over ten years ago and the new Making Tax Digital regime finally launches for income tax on April  6, the start of the new tax year 2026. It is already in place for VAT returns. It looks like a nightmare for the self-employed and landlords who will be forced to comply.

Landlords and the self-employed face the awful choice of paying hundreds of pounds for HMRC-approved software to complete these returns or paying hundreds of pounds a year for an accountant to do it for you.

HMRC tells us that free software is available for those with simple finances, (though they themselves don’t supply any for you to use, natch), but other experts think the average business would pay more than £300 for software.

It is yet another tax on individuals and businesses.

And it is something you are all already paying for. Back in 2023 the National Audit Office warned the cost of the project had already got out of control with the original 2016 cost estimate of £226m now expected to cost an extra £1bn. And it is likely to go higher still.

And it is not over yet. In the 2025 Spring Statement, the Chancellor expanded the Making Tax Digital (MTD) net – so now an extra 900,000 sole traders and property investors will be forced to comply from April 2028. This is when the threshold, which determines whether you must use the new reporting system, drops from £50,000 of annual turnover to just £20,000. So, all buy-to-let properties are almost certain to be hit.

Insultingly, HMRC claim it will “reduce time spent on record-keeping and tax administration”.

Hmmm, OK. Er, exactly how will it do that? They must be laughing at us.

As the Telegraph lead said, “As per usual, HMRC seems more intent on squeezing individuals with relatively low levels of untaxed income – such as those flogging second-hand clothes online – rather than the enormous corporations that find ever more inventive ways to dodge serious amounts of tax”.

Despite politicians repeated promises to cut red tape, the opposite keeps happening. The only winners will be the companies flogging confused taxpayers’ software “solutions”.

An HMRC spokesman said MTD was on track to launch in April and claimed it would “drive efficiency and raise more money for public services, as well as making it easier for taxpayers to stay on top of their affairs”.

How on earth is that supposed to work and exactly what planet do these people live on? Answer – the planet of the featherbedded government employee with no clue about the real world and how hard it is to run a small business.

Personally, I have not got a clue how I am going to make this work. To date, I simply write down all my costs and incomes on a simple spreadsheet – line by line – with a copy of each cost going into a notebook, then I spend a day and a half in mid-January, (just before final deadline day for the prior year ending for the tax year ending the prior April), carefully splitting the heads of costs into the appropriate six or seven categories – and I have to split some 50/50 where my wife co-owns them – same thing on rents and interest on the mortgages.

There are lots of landlords like me – and I know that lots of other landlords are selling up. The people who want to rent my properties are mostly telling me they are moving because their landlord is getting out. I have never experienced so many cases as this before in 35 years of letting.

The reality is that this is the straw that breaks the back of many landlords, especially the many older ones who are not tech savvy.

And of course, as in any market, less supply = increased prices, in this case, increased rents. Utter clownworld! It is again, the tenants who pay the price of repeated attacks on landlords. And it is consumers who have to pay the increased cost of compliance suffered by small traders and businesses.

It is insane and I don’t see how it can be faster for HMRC either. Or save them money.

As the costs of the software or paying an accountant are tax deductible, as an extra 900,000 people have to do it, each spending £300 more on software per year or to give to an accountant to take the pain away – and if each pays 40% tax, then the government has just lost £108m in tax by making people comply with this idiocy. And that does not count the extra time one will have to take out from making money, (and earning income that could be taxed), and spending that time instead submitting returns five times a year.

And what exactly is their issue here? Why can we not just complete entries online and direct onto the HMRC system. (It would be a pain but I would suffer doing it four times a year on top of the annual one we do now). It makes absolutely no sense to me.

This idea came about under the Tories. But Labour promised to tread lightly on citizens. And yet this “treading lightly” reminds me of the section in George Orwell’s book, “1984”, where he referred to the state thus: “Imagine a boot stamping on your face forever”. Treading lightly! I do not think so.

There may not be a good reason other than it is just another attempt to get rid of the small Mom and Pop landlords and replace them with big corporations. And to replace small traders generally with bigger businesses. In the private rent space, they know many landlords are old and could not tell a piece of software from a soft banana. They know it will be too much for them.

As Klaus Schwab and the WEF put it: “You will own nothing, (especially two or more properties directly,) and you will be happy”.

But Wait. In the November budget, it was stated that fines for not submitting this way will not be imposed for the first 12 months. So, maybe you should ignore it for now and pray the whole silly idea goes away for good before April 2027. After, all if everyone ignored it and didn’t do it, maybe the government and HMRC would think again. And as at end of February, only 5% of landlords and small traders have registered, so maybe that could work?

Here is a link to the government’s own site here: https://www.gov.uk/guidance/sign-up-your-business-for-making-tax-digital-for-income-tax where it says, “If you’re required to use Making Tax Digital for Income Tax from 6 April 2026, HMRC will not apply penalty points for late quarterly updates for the first tax year (2026 to 2027). Penalties will still apply for late tax returns or if you pay your tax bill after the due date. If you’re signing up voluntarily, make sure you understand what penalties apply if you’re volunteering for Making Tax Digital for Income Tax. HMRC will contact you to confirm when you’ve become liable for these penalties after you’ve signed up.”

Who the heck would volunteer and risk penalties? Is that not risky in itself?

Finally, I am very disappointed that the National Residential Landlords Association (NRLA) has not seen fit to publicise the fact fines won’t be applied in the first year to their members . These days, they truly are too much the poodles of the government.

HMRC is just an agency of the state too, so if you don’t like any of this, remember it all came in as a plan under the Tories and has been extended with great glee under Labour. So, why not send them both a message next time you are asked to vote!

An election is coming up very soon, maybe send a message.

Link to other articles on this: https://www.lettingfocus.com/blogs/tag/making-tax-digital

Services for Private Landlords and Organisations

We help landlords and property investors by showing them how to make money in the private rented sector using ways which are fair to tenants and which involve minimal risk. Our advice is completely independent.

We also advise a range of organisations too – public, charities and private – to help them develop and improve their services and products for private landlords.

HOME PAGE : Home – Letting Focus

For general information on our CONSULTING SERVICES: Consultancy and Seminars

For ONE-TO-ONE PRIVATE CONSULTANCY FOR PRIVATE LANDLORDS: Property Advice

IN THE MEDIA: Recent Press Coverage

BOOKS:

“SUCCESSFUL PROPERTY LETTING”:

Click here to Find Out More and Buy it. And if you are from an organisation and would like to bulk buy, please ask us for special rates.

“BUY TO LET LANDLORDS GUIDE TO FINDING GREAT TENANTS”:

Also, get this, which covers everything you’ll ever need to know to avoid either you or your letting agent getting anyone other than the perfect tenant. Click Here to Buy It.

BOOK FOR TENANTS:

Kids going off and renting for the first time? My Book for Tenants is also Available

TO JOIN OUR FREE NEWSLETTER MAILER which goes to over 3,960 people (as at December 2023) just send an email to david@LettingFocus.com

We do not send spam or sell our mailing list to advertisers, though we occasionally mail landlords about good products from third parties. Please put us on your “white-list” to ensure you receive our emails.

OFFERS ON PRODUCTS FOR LANDLORDS and TO ADVERTISE YOUR PRODUCTS to LANDLORDS: Landlords Resources

TWITTER / X:

Twitter banned me twice permanently for life. (I may be the only person that has ever happened to!?). After three years and two months, I finally got round to appealing again, hoping the new ownership would allow me back on. They did! So, I am back on and so are my 7,000 plus followers : Twitter 

4 comments

  • Excellent blog and both landlords and the self-employed are the focus of this govt who along with the Tories are increasingly designating many independent and private sector earners as the “new Kulaks”as you’ve mentioned before. Since the authorities probably can’t impose a digital identity direct they are carefully crafting one using initiatives like this. Watch crypto become regulated too as they cut off the opportunity to have an alternative to fiat money that gives security and anonymity from the state’s eyes.

    • “Since the authorities probably can’t impose a digital identity direct they are carefully crafting one using initiatives like this”.
      Yes, it is this in a nutshell. Small steps taken round the back to create the digital prison.

  • This idea is aimed at private landlords and trying to fracture the rental market. A pilot run has already proved disastrous and expensive.

    The Government talks about helping renters and workers yet conspires to make life much more difficult with constant changes in legislation

    . This is yet another white elephant along with HS2 and The green energy plant Drax in Yorkshire that imports wooden pellet from trees cut down in Canada and America which are then transported by diesel ships halfway round the world to satisfy Millermads green aspirations.

    • Indeed. And I like the word MILLIMAD… Very good, I usually use the term Millivolt, as that captures both the max electrical pulse probably going on in his brain as well as what is generated on a still, grey, anticyclonic day in mid winter in the UK.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.