Warm Homes Plan Could Well Be a Repeat of the Green Deal Nonsense

A reminder of the staggering waste of taxpayers cash under the Green Deal scheme.

“So, it had cost £14,000 per household to provide an average loan of £3,600. Only the State can do business this badly”

“The problem is that people who work in the state sector don’t even come close to understanding commercial realities “.

Oh luck! Households will be eligible for thousands of pounds of solar panels and other green stuff to lower their energy bills, as the Warm Homes Plan promises to provide £15billion to households across the UK over the next five years in an aim to triple the number of homes with solar technology, and lift a million people out of fuel poverty.

Some of you who are old enough may recall Chris Huhne’s Green Deal of the 2010-2015 coalition government. 

This resulted in massive fraud as money for “improvements” was often given away. There was a lack of auditing with approximately a quarter of a billion wasted before the scheme was cancelled. It could all happen again with Warm Front.

The Green Deal was designed to improve the energy efficiency of more than 14 million homes by 2020. The idea was for property owners to install energy efficiency improvements at no upfront cost, with the costs being recouped through the property owner’s energy bill over several years.

So far, so good.

There was a Green Deal Finance Company set up, which actually acted rather like a bank. The scheme lent money to householders, it had a depositor and lender of last resort in the taxpayer. The Green Deal Providers had to be certified by the Financial Conduct Authority. Yep, sure sounds like a bank to me.

During the coalition, the Department for Energy and Climate Change (DECC) was one of the departments whose cabinet-level position was given out to the Liberal Democrats. But the scheme was sold as a flagship policy for the coalition.

Chris Huhne, whom you may recall, later quit the Commons when he was convicted of perverting the course of justice over a speeding ticket, was the Minister responsible. He was given eight months in prison and served just two. (50% of time actually served is for the little people).

The idea behind the Green Deal was that householders would borrow money to pay for improvements to improve energy efficiency. However, they would not pay off the loan directly; instead, the payments would be taken from their energy bills. The golden rule was that the amount paid by the household in paying off the loan should not exceed the energy savings provided by the improvements. The work was to be performed by approved suppliers and contractors.

The official launch of this scheme took place in January 2013.

But by late summer 2013, the uptake of the scheme was just 133 homes out of a national housing stock of 27million.

The scheme made loans at rates of between 7-10 per cent and was meant to be self-financing and after start up costs paid for by the state, the private sector was meant to step in.

After all, selling loans for 7 per cent after borrowing money on the market for, say, 4 per cent (at the time) sounds like easy peasy money. And it should be.

But success depended on householders being willing to borrow the money at 7 per cent, plus there was an initial cost to consumers of about £150 for a household energy assessment.

Lots of people signed up for the assessment – with 50,000 houses being tested. But the conversion rate from assessment to loan take-up was appalling. With just 133 loans, the scheme was clearly not self-financing. Green Deal had been set up expecting an uptake of millions.

Why was the uptake so low?

One clue may be that the underlying objective was to reduce carbon emissions. Energy production is a complex business and has been further complicated by the whole global warming scandal.

The release of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere has, of course, long been monetised. One consequence of this has been that energy-intensive businesses in this country, like steel production and chemicals, are now saddled with another financial burden which overseas competitors do not have, which is why so many heavy industrial businesses are struggling and shutting up shop.

More generally, commerce in the UK is being hobbled due to a bonkers belief that our climate is changing and it’s all due to man’s activities, but climatology is a relatively new discipline compared with physics with little evidence to support it. (The state broadcaster, however, thinks the “science is settled” and allows no debate).

You have to wonder why exactly the state was trying to act like a home improvement finance house.

State services are usually those that the private sector will not or cannot perform.

The trouble is that UK’s rather good financial services sector could not fashion a product to incentivise people to insulate their homes, so that should tell anyone with half a brain that there is no money in it and that disaster would surely follow.

Throwing money at the problem, which is what governments like to do, is a feeble way of improving things – and rarely works.

Green Deal – An Abject Failure

The Green Deal was wound down shortly after the 2015 General Election, after £240million had been spent. About 14,000 loans had been taken out, around 0.1 per cent of the target.

The growth from the pitiful 133 loans to the still pathetic14,000 can be explained by the increasingly expensive incentives, (i.e. taxpayers hard earned cash thrown at the problem), that the government offered. These included cashbacks (£16million), promotion through local government (£106million), and “other programme, administration and capital expenditure” at a truly mind boggling £72million.

In 2012, DECC forecast that the Green Deal Finance Company would provide loans worth more than £1.1billion by the end of 2015. The actual figure by that date was £50million.

So, it had cost £14,000 per household to provide an average loan of £3,600. Only the State can do business this badly.

Two hundred and forty million pounds spent on this is a huge number, though these days it looks like peanuts in terms of other figures.

For example, the national debt is £3.1 trillion and the interest payment on it is £110 billion per annum. We wasted a cool £37bn just on test and trace under convid, before our government admitted it didn’t work, (It could never have worked, of course, as anyone with any knowledge of virology will tell you, unless they are virologists who also happen to be in the pay of Big Pharma, but that is a whole other story).

Our housing stock does need to be more energy-efficient, everyone can agree on that, but selling home improvements is a difficult business and cowboy builders abound in the sector. One in ten of the “approved” contractors had their accreditation withdrawn.

Once the Conservatives were free of their coalition partners, they ditched the scheme. The National Audit Office investigated and found The Green Deal was effectively a state-sponsored home-improvement finance business – but one that did not act like a business.

The problem is that people who work in the state sector don’t even come close to understanding commercial realities and do not understand competition unless they want to crimp it.

Our elected representatives in Parliament did not really scrutinise the Green Deal, neither did opposition MPs. But then questioning green policies is usually seen as a heresy, certainly it was in those days, though things are slightly better now.

The Green Deal seems to have been above politics, a sort of technocratic sacred cow. No one was blamed; no one was criticised. Everybody involved gets to keep their cozy index-linked pension.

Sadly, there is no deterrence to a repeat of this waste of time, effort and money. The business of government goes on and on. The national debt increases. We, our children, grandchildren, and so on get to pay for it all in return for a vote every five years.

Oh lucky us!

See also about this colossal waste of money on another more recent green related scheme, which I have covered in another post: https://www.lettingfocus.com/blogs/2026/01/private-landlords-have-even-less-chance-now-of-achieving-energy-performance-ratings-of-c-by-the-2030-deadline-due-to-botched-eco-and-gbis-schemes/

Services for Private Landlords and Organisations

We help landlords and property investors by showing them how to make money in the private rented sector using ways which are fair to tenants and which involve minimal risk. Our advice is completely independent.

We also advise a range of organisations too – public, charities and private – to help them develop and improve their services and products for private landlords.

HOME PAGE : Home – Letting Focus

For general information on our CONSULTING SERVICES: Consultancy and Seminars

For ONE-TO-ONE PRIVATE CONSULTANCY FOR PRIVATE LANDLORDS: Property Advice

IN THE MEDIA: Recent Press Coverage

BOOKS:

“SUCCESSFUL PROPERTY LETTING”:

Click here to Find Out More and Buy it. And if you are from an organisation and would like to bulk buy, please ask us for special rates.

“BUY TO LET LANDLORDS GUIDE TO FINDING GREAT TENANTS”:

Also, get this, which covers everything you’ll ever need to know to avoid either you or your letting agent getting anyone other than the perfect tenant. Click Here to Buy It.

BOOK FOR TENANTS:

Kids going off and renting for the first time? My Book for Tenants is also Available

TO JOIN OUR FREE NEWSLETTER MAILER which goes to over 3,960 people (as at December 2023) just send an email to david@LettingFocus.com

We do not send spam or sell our mailing list to advertisers, though we occasionally mail landlords about good products from third parties. Please put us on your “white-list” to ensure you receive our emails.

OFFERS ON PRODUCTS FOR LANDLORDS and TO ADVERTISE YOUR PRODUCTS to LANDLORDS: Landlords Resources

TWITTER / X:

Twitter banned me twice permanently for life. (I may be the only person that has ever happened to!?). After three years and two months, I finally got round to appealing again, hoping the new ownership would allow me back on. They did! So, I am back on and so are my 7,000 plus followers : Twitter 

2 comments

  • Excellent summary of why politicians should not have a cheque book nor listen to unelected bodies like the Climate Change Committee who are infested with the green ideology, never mind “oh it’s only money and the rich will pay” mentality”! Before any party or politician is allowed near the keys to Downing Street all their election manifesto should be costed by private sector bean counters with analysis also provided by economists who know how to consider incentives, trade offs and the perils of bureaucratic spending. If an elected politician or bureaucrat then goes off piste they should be held personally liable for wasted expenditure. We owe a tougher and more accountable approach to our kids and their kids.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.