Landlords Walk Away, Rents Increase, Tenants Have to Jump Through Near-Impossible Hoops to Rent a Property
Thirty thousand small landlords in the UK walked away from the private rented sector in the year to April 2025. And that’s before the Renters’ Rights Act had even taken effect in England.
The Telegraph reports that the number of small landlords fell for the first time in five years, while the income they declared also dropped.
Since that time, landlords have been hit by the Renters’ Rights Act, higher stamp duty on additional properties and the ongoing effects of a tax regime that has steadily made personally owned buy to let less attractive.
The government, ever since George Osborne was Chancellor, have been gradually making this business sector less attractive, so cannot be surprised when the people running those businesses decide to walk away.
Let us not forget that Section 24, higher stamp duty and the original drive to abolish Section 21 were on the Tory’s watch.
Labour has just made the situation worse.
The Renters’ Rights Act has just put more risk and uncertainty on landlords. Possession is now much more complicated and protracted, regulation is heavier and the penalties are much bigger.
Property competes for capital with other uses and, of course, the landlords do not have remain landlords.
Money can get an acceptable return without regulation, licensing, possession proceedings and the possibility of a £40,000 civil penalty. Five-year fixed rate bonds offer risk free 5% right now (albeit before tax), which for many landlords looks increasingly tempting. And no need to bother with Making tax Digital either.
When landlords sell, some of the properties may go to first-time buyers, but not all that many.
The reality is that the UK student, the foreign student, the family unable to yet secure a mortgage, the household saving for a deposit, the worker on a temporary contract away from home, the young professional moving for a job, the recently divorced all have need of a vibrant private rented sector, which can act quickly to house them.
With fewer landlords competing for this still large pool of tenants, unsurprisingly rents have been increasing – and the Renters’ Rights Act has only made rent increases bigger.
In a nutshell, one cannot improve affordability by driving suppliers from a supply-constrained market. One cannot increase choice by reducing the number of homes available. And one cannot keep transferring risk and cost onto landlords and hope and pray that none of this will eventually hit tenants as higher rents.
The bigger question is what the PRS looks like in the future.
It looks like the hope is that institutional investors, (such as Macquarie Bank and Lloyds,) and large corporate landlords (such as Unite and Grainger) will take a greater share of the market.
But who knows.
Certainly, our leaders seem to prefer this sort of “big boy” investors to smaller scale landlords, who own say one to five terraced houses or flats.
I recall the FT some years ago reported research which found tenants much preferred to deal with smaller scale landlords and found the corporate players hard to deal with, hidden behind call centres and menu options and with rents always set to market rents. (Smaller scale landlords tended to keep annual rent increases low, so as not to lose tenants – and there is ample evidence that many tenants who have been in the same property for five or more years are paying ten to twenty percent below local newly advertised rents. The small landlords were also more flexible on a late rental payment too)
As a result of the new Act, landlords are increasingly asking for guarantors – who of course must be UK homeowners with enough clear income to pay the rent if a tenant defaults. Data from HomeLet shows the share of accepted applications requiring a guarantor has risen from around 9% in January 2025 to over 18% in July 2026, with almost one in five lets now agreed with a guarantor in place. Lots of people cannot find suitable guarantors who meet the requirements of landlords and letting agents. Naturally, this is a huge problem for overseas students who will likely not know any UK homeowners. More on this below.
Government seems to take no heed of the substantial tax revenue that comes to the Treasury through income tax on rental profits, Stamp Duty Land Tax, Capital Gains Tax and other property-related taxes. Plus, they have overlooked that the private rented sector also supports a great amount of economic activity through refurbishment, maintenance, professional services and construction.
Landlords have traditionally purchased a significant proportion of new-build properties, sometimes at an early stage of development. With that demand and support gone, developments become less attractive.
And who do the corporate landlords like Lloyds cater for? Sure, they will supply me-too identikit flats for young executives. They are not interested in family homes – such as the typical terrace, the bedrock of small landlords.
It is perfectly possible that low-income family homes, if they are provided at all by these corporations, will be in dense developments, supported by government subsidies. Housing will effectively be part-nationalised.
Student housing is particularly hard hit by the Renters’ Rights Act.
Student housing was for years, a well-functioning market, clearly understood by students, landlords and agents. Groups of students would get together, go viewing in October through to January, book their house for the next academic year, move in August or September and move out at end July or whenever the contract specified.
The Renters’ Rights Act has broken this in every aspect. No contracts can be signed more than 6 months before the tenancy start – that completely messes up the plans of the organised groups that like to get sorted before Christmas.
And getting rid of fixed terms is insane, given the natural cycle is the academic year. Individual students can now give notice at any time – which is a problem for both the landlord and their housemates. And as no more than one month rent in advance can be charged, this is a big problem for those UK students who don’t have a guarantor benefactor and for all overseas students.
I hope that the coming budget will break with recent tradition and won’t hurt the private sector even more. Surely, they can see the damage that has been caused. In the last week, the new PM ignored Jeremy Corbyn’s daft plea for rent controls, which is at least a good thing.
Dare we hope that the penny has finally dropped?
Services for Private Landlords and Organisations
We help landlords and property investors by showing them how to make money in the private rented sector using ways which are fair to tenants and which involve minimal risk. Our advice is completely independent.
We also advise a range of organisations too – public, charities and private – to help them develop and improve their services and products for private landlords.
HOME PAGE : Home – Letting Focus
For general information on our CONSULTING SERVICES: Consultancy and Seminars
For ONE-TO-ONE PRIVATE CONSULTANCY FOR PRIVATE LANDLORDS: Property Advice
IN THE MEDIA: Recent Press Coverage
BOOKS:
“SUCCESSFUL PROPERTY LETTING”:
Click here to Find Out More and Buy it. And if you are from an organisation and would like to bulk buy, please ask us for special rates.
“BUY TO LET LANDLORDS GUIDE TO FINDING GREAT TENANTS”:
Also, get this, which covers everything you’ll ever need to know to avoid either you or your letting agent getting anyone other than the perfect tenant. Click Here to Buy It.
BOOK FOR TENANTS:
Kids going off and renting for the first time? My Book for Tenants is also Available
TO JOIN OUR FREE NEWSLETTER MAILER which goes to over 3,960 people (as at December 2023) just send an email to david@LettingFocus.com
We do not send spam or sell our mailing list to advertisers, though we occasionally mail landlords about good products from third parties. Please put us on your “white-list” to ensure you receive our emails.
OFFERS ON PRODUCTS FOR LANDLORDS and TO ADVERTISE YOUR PRODUCTS to LANDLORDS: Landlords Resources
.
Another excellent blog bemoaning the threats to the private rental sector and the knock on effects on those our uniparty govt’s don’t realise will hopefully turn on them. The current malaise goes back several generations and the wrong turnings and bad decisions just can’t be a coincidence, it must be part of a coordinated grand plan as yet unrevealed to the public. Your faith in the new PM though is I’m afraid to say “clutching at straws” as everything he does is not for our benefit, but that of his already well-heeled patrons that seemingly want to see the U.K. hobbled and ultimately destroyed. We need patriotic leadership at all levels and through out the executive, administrative and judicial state and soon, otherwise we’ll become simply a vassal state bordering on serfdom that our ancestors fought centuries to overturn!
All the evidence does point to a plan, and it is not for the good of the UK and its people.
Great commentary as always – thank you. If you think of the growth of the sector when Section 21 was introduced – Section 21 was a catalyst for growth of the sector (there were of course other factors such as MIRAS). With the removal of Section 21 the sector will go into reverse and its the end game for the sector as we know it sadly. I do not think the people who are making these decisions really understand it and that is very worrying for all aspects of our government not just housing. I feel like this is the charge of the light brigade!
Thanks Tom, excellent comment.
Spot on, David. We are seeing the same here in Surrey — smaller landlords weighing up whether the extra regulation is worth it, and a good number deciding it is not. The irony is that a good independent letting agent actually helps landlords stay compliant and profitable through all of this; the ones walking away often never had that support. Brookwood Lettings & Management, independent letting agent in Addlestone — https://brookwoodlettings.co.uk/