Block Viewings and Bidding Wars
This article is about block viewings and bidding wars for rental property and why one rarely exists and the other is a unicorn, existing only in the imagination of out-of-touch politicos who don’t understand the private rented sector.
Block Viewings and The Tenants Bidding War Unicorn
I have seen some daft ideas touted about what could be Labour policy for the private rented sector.
There is one story about how landlords could be prevented from evicting non-paying tenants if it caused the tenants “hardship”. That’s a good one! Good luck with the long run supply of new rentals if you run with that silly idea.
Another one, which was also much talked about pre-election, was about stopping bidding wars for rental properties.
Now a bright person would suggest there might be something wrong with a market if there are bidding wars for something in the first place.
Let that thought rest. Mmm.
Of course, bidding wars are OK at an auction to buy/sell a property or to buy a trinket. You kind of expect that – and note that bidders’ ability to pay is usually checked beforehand at such events.
But bidding wars for rental property? Really?
Does that happen? Would it happen?
Would that really be the most efficient way for landlords to select tenants?
So, this is how Labour wonks, sitting in their comfy Islington flats, post PPE at Oxford and post a spell at the Policy Exchange must envisage it working:
Landlords hold an open viewing day, lots of desperate would-be tenants turn up to view the property, the mean landlords choose between tenants based on what they can afford and slink off, Shylock-like to bank their huge gains.
A recent NRLA magazine piece ran a series of interviews with landlords asking them their thoughts about block open day type viewings.
Answer: These were not popular at all.
And with good reason – that is not how things work in the real world.
Landlords never invite round groups of random applicants to view their properties. Apart from the security angle, it would be a pointless exercise.
Any landlord knows that even with all the checks that the likes of OpenRent put on and with all the landlords’ own attempts to put off the many time wasters who make contact, there are still many time wasters and non-serious applicants who filter through anyway.
All landlords must spend real time hard yards on email or the phone, wheedling out the “possibly good applicants”. But even then, there are plenty of time wasters who come to your viewings who will suddenly remember they have a dog, suddenly recall an old CCJ, suddenly remember they have four kids and not just the one, suddenly be unable to produce the documents you wish to see.
Certain, ahem, nationalities, are particularly at fault for this, but of course, in this febrile environment I cannot say which.
Even with the screening services that OpenRent apply, plus our own clear messaging in our ads, it works like this:
From the resulting 50 enquiries that get through the OpenRent filter, we will usually get maybe eight viewings. Typically, one might say the property is “not for them”, which is daft as they ought to have checked out the photos and place before hand – as well as our super competitive rents.
Five or six will “uhm and ahh”, but somehow not be able to get us all the documents we need to see. (We do tell them in advance, but a lot of them, certain nationalities in particular, evidently think we can be persuaded to drop our strict criteria, post- viewings. We can’t!).
That will leave just one or two serious applicants.
Occasionally, we must choose between two.
There are no bidding wars because if you have priced your rent correctly, there are only two serious candidates that emerge who can provide proof that they can really afford the rent and make good tenants.
But the people sitting in their comfy Islington flats, post their Oxford PPE degrees and post a stint as an intern at Policy Exchange and who are now making policy for Labour have absolutely no understanding of how the real world works. Not just Labour, the Tories showed themselves to be almost as out-of-touch whilst in government.
Services for Private Landlords
We help landlords and property investors by showing them how to make money in the private rented sector using ways which are fair to tenants and which involve minimal risk. Our advice is completely independent.
We also advise a range of organisations too – public, charities and private – to help them develop and improve their services and products for private landlords.
HOME PAGE : Home – Letting Focus
For general information on our CONSULTING SERVICES: Consultancy and Seminars
For ONE-TO-ONE PRIVATE CONSULTANCY FOR PRIVATE LANDLORDS: Property Advice
IN THE MEDIA: Recent Press Coverage
BOOKS:
“SUCCESSFUL PROPERTY LETTING”:
Click here to Find Out More and Buy it. And if you are from an organisation and would like to bulk buy, please ask us for special rates.
“BUY TO LET LANDLORDS GUIDE TO FINDING GREAT TENANTS”:
Also, get this, which covers everything you’ll ever need to know to avoid either you or your letting agent getting anyone other than the perfect tenant. Click Here to Buy It.
BOOK FOR TENANTS:
Kids going off and renting for the first time? My Book for Tenants is also Available
TO JOIN OUR FREE NEWSLETTER MAILER which goes to over 3,960 people (as at December 2023) just send an email to david@LettingFocus.com
We do not send spam or sell our mailing list to advertisers, though we occasionally mail landlords about good products from third parties. Please put us on your “white-list” to ensure you receive our emails.
OFFERS ON PRODUCTS FOR LANDLORDS and TO ADVERTISE YOUR PRODUCTS to LANDLORDS: Landlords Resources
TWITTER PAGE Twitter has banned me twice permanently for life. (I was unbanned permanently once, I may be the only person that has ever happened to!?). The ban is for having “Wrong Thoughts” and “Provoking Quarrels” mainly about coercive Convid injections, “vaccine” mandates and house arrest policies, but they may relent and put me back live again, one of these days and when I can be bothered to appeal: Twitter
Read your latest newsletter David. A particularly interesting one.
Here’s some feedback on the Block Viewing article. It’s based on experience and written from the perspective of someone who:
a) is a landlord
b) has recently rented
c) occasionally shows people around rental properties when the agent is unable to do the viewing themselves
Most obviously, it’s from the perspective of those landlords who instruct agents to do the tenant-finding for them. And so here, for your interest…
** DO BIDDING WARS HAPPEN? **
YES, in South East London they do (although use of the word ‘war’ is somewhat hyperbolic, especially given the world situation at present).
Since at least Aug 2022 (the date from which I first became aware of the practice), viewers to popular properties are informed that if they remain interested in taking the place, they should submit their ‘full and final offer’ by a particular deadline (usually, in my experience, by midday the following day). In this respect, the process is, indeed, similar to making an offer to buy a property, except, of course, one can assume that for in-demand properties, the rental offer should exceed the advertised figure.
When, in Aug 20222, I found a flat I wanted to rent for myself and partner, the published rent was £2,200pcm. Demand for all rentals at the time was particularly high and so I offered £2,250pcm. We secured the place. Did we offer the most? I don’t know. Could we have secured it for less? Possibly, since we had rapport with the agent and were, though I say so myself, high grade candidates: provable cash in the bank, one in secure employment, one a landlord. But we offered more because we didn’t want to risk losing the place for the sake of £50pcm. Good result for us – we got the place we wanted – and a bonus outcome for the landlord. The deal was done in 24 hours – beautifully efficient.
I’ve done block viewings myself. A plus point is that attendees can see for themselves that demand for the place is high – it’s apparent/transparent. If you know you have ropey references and then see the volume of other couples at the viewing, you surely know you’re going to be an unlikely winner. Why even bother submitting an offer? Contrast this with taking the word of an agent or landlord that the rent is keenly priced because “trust me, it’s a popular and desirable rental and I’ve got lots of people interested in it. Honest.”
More recently I’ve shown students around properties. There’s plenty of demand and, of course, parents are guarantors (and so, all things being equal, all groups are probably as good as one another in terms of security). Most groups of students know that to secure the place they need to act fast (i.e. get your references in asap) and often have an expectation they may have to offer more than the advertised rent to beat another the groups of students (or should I say, parents). There’s an efficiency in the way this all works.
In all of these examples, no pre-vetting was/is done. Qualification and reference checking is done when offers are received. Different from your way of working, I know.
** SHOULD BIDDING WARS HAPPEN? **
If there was more rental supply (in South East London), then they probably wouldn’t happen. You allude to this.
Could the landlord/agent pitch the rent so perfectly that they alight up the perfect tenant, plus a reserve candidate? Maybe, but why take the risk (of extending a void) by getting too few suitable candidates? Get the applicants in, then vet them, starting with the highest bidder first.
** WHY HAVE BLOCK VIEWINGS? **
For some agencies block viewings are a necessity, since they don’t have the resource to conduct multiple back-to-back viewings. If there are 8 interested parties, that’s 4 hours plus travel time chewed up, assuming 30 minutes per party. (Whilst 15 minutes is typically sufficient for the viewing itself, as you will know, some people turn up early, some late, some linger. Trying to squeeze lots of people into a short timescale can mean individual viewings overlap to become, in effect, a group viewing.) Whilst viewings could be spread over several days, the risk here is that the first viewers may find somewhere else while they wait for the landlord to make their mind up.
You might say, in response, well landlords shouldn’t use under-resourced (small) agencies. I would counter by saying I don’t want to do the tenant finding myself: I’m happy to devolve responsibility and to get an agent to do the legwork using their preferred method. Just find me some fully-vetted prospective tenants and then we can discuss and decide on a preferred candidate. At this point, subjectivity usually comes into play: who do I feel is the safest, most secure, most long-term etc.
** DAFT FOR VIEWERS TO SAY A PROPERTY IS NOT FOR THEM? **
Not at all, because photos don’t tell the full story. I’ve shown people round places which appeared fantastic in the listing, but which stank of dog/cigarettes, or which had crappy or unsecure communal areas. I’ve also viewed places where the sound of a nearby business or building works is intermittingly intrusive.
Keep up the good work!
Excellent comments, Rupert.
I think I may need to go back and amend this one to clarify what I was saying here.
All very good points raised.
I do think and hope that decent letting agents really ought to be spending some time up front (as soon as they get an enquiry) and sorting the serious applicants from the rest, not least that it is better to do it then, than to waste time attending a viewing, (yours and theirs), with an applicant who will simply not be suitable – which is usually because 1) they cannot afford it 2) they want to cram about eight family members in your 2 bed house 3) they have a dog. These are the prime reasons, though there are others too. And it all goes back to them having not read the advert and qualifying criteria properly.
Doing viewings all on the same morning or evening does make sense though. We like to spread them 15-20 mins apart, so that as one applicant leaves, another is knocking at the door, which creates its own demand, plus we tell them all that we will be seeing four sets of applicant, that evening, so they need to be on time.
What we don’t do and we don’t think agents should either is having applicants randomly roaming around a property in some sort of open-day free-for-all. This is because in such a scenario you cannot get to know any of the applicants at all – and if the existing tenants are still in occupation with their stuff around, it is a complete NO NO from a security and a respect for tenants point of view. (Unlike lots of letting agents we don’t do voids, so our viewings mainly take place before the old tenants have left, unless we are planning to do a major refurb when the previous tenants have left).
I still don’t like this offers over bidding type system. As I say, the property should be priced right – and I would not enter into a bidding situation at all, in fact I have had many cases where, when having to choose between two good applicants, one or more of the applicants has offered to pay more to get the property.
In these situations I would rather look harder at each of their applications and find a way to choose one over the other for other sound commercial reasons. Often it might come down to having a more secure job, the probability of them staying longer, being practical (e.g. they can fix the sticky drawer themselves) or just that I feel they will be better customers and nicer people to deal with.
And I then make my decision based on one or more of these factors.
I do think this is how agents should operate on behalf of their landlords – as most landlords want good tenants who stay long and will definitely pay the rent rather than a higher rent from a tenant who is slightly less attractive a proposition.
On the odd, rare occasion when I have underpriced it too much, I just take it on the chin and, of course, I can always increase the rent next year on the anniversary (when we review all rents).
BTW I haven’t got a clue how on earth bidding wars could be prevented by statute, it is ridiculous. The reality is, if landlords and agents want to do it, and there is no trail in writing, the losing applicant in such a war is a) never likely to find out why they missed out or b) be able to prove a bidding war happened anyway.