Mortgage Lending Over Caution. Interest Coverage Ratios Are Ludicrous

Mortgage Lending Over Caution – Interest Cover Ratios are Ludicrous. My Experience

Despite getting a rent which today is 70 per cent more than when I bought a house back in 2010, I have just found I can still only get a mortgage which is around the same monetary amount that I got back then, despite the value of the house more than doubling in that time!

In 2010, the mortgage I obtained worked out at 76% of the value of the house. Today, the maximum mortgage I can get works out at less than 40% of the value of that same property today. This is all a result of the ludicrous and overcautious Interest Coverage Ratios that all lenders are now forced to apply, combined with the over high interest rates they use in making these calculations. Tell me about your experience.  

Back in January 2010 I bought a two-bedroom house.

The house was bought for £203,500, the buy to let mortgage that I bought it with was £156,475, so approximately a 76% loan to value. The rate was 2 per cent above the Bank of England Base rate for the whole life of the mortgage. Of course, these days, rates that are at a set amount above the BOE base rate for life, (or for any time period for that matter), don’t exist anymore, they are just too risky for the lenders. I have one that is still running at 0.69% above BOE base, obviously I am in no hurry to remortgage on that one. It still has another four years to run!

In those days, in 2010, we were still suffering the aftershocks of the Great Financial Crash (GFC), which started in 2008, so in those days lenders were slightly cautious and the margins over base rates were highish – hence this one being at a relatively high 2 per cent over Bank of England base. At that time, in the shadow of the GFC, all was doom and gloom in the housing market too, so I bought this property and two others between 2009 and 2011 at what later turned out to be very good prices indeed. Since then, all three houses have more than doubled in value.

(Digression: I am a firm believer that it is often a smarter idea to buy property (and shares too) when everyone is running scared than when confidence abounds. You just need guts that’s all – and access to finance, which at such times can, unfortunately, be in short supply. And it is for this reason that property investors like to keep some cash available so they can move in and buy property at good prices with most or all their own cash, (and without the need to be constrained by lending, which can be in short supply during times of financial crises)).

For quite a few years after 2010, a base rate tracker of 2 per cent over base was not a bad rate, but things have changed a lot in the last five years and much better rates than this are now available, though, as I said, no base rate trackers exist today. But there are some very good five-year fixed rate deals around (if you are OK with a fix) and some decent discounted rate deals too, (discounted off the SVR rate), and these are OK but, of course, there is no guarantee that the SVR will fall when the central bank cuts the base rate.

Anyway, the point is that for at least five years now, I admit, I should have long since remortgaged onto a better rate than 2 per cent over base rate.

So, I have just started looking around to remortgage this loan. It was then that I realised just how stupidly cautious mortgage lending now is. And it is mostly the fault of the regulators (for which read the government).

Despite getting a rent which is 70 per cent more than when I bought the house back in 2010, I have just found I can only get a mortgage which is around the same monetary amount that I got back then, despite the value of the house more than doubling in that time!

In 2010, the mortgage I obtained worked out at 76% of the value of the house. Today, the maximum mortgage I can get works out at less than 40% of the value of that same property today.

Why is this?

Well, it is all a result of the ludicrous and overcautious Interest Cover Ratios (or Interest Coverage Ratios (ICRs)) that all lenders now apply, combined with the over high and over cautious interest rates they use in making these calculations.

The ICR is used to assess a landlord’s ability to pay the mortgage on a buy-to-let rental property, whether it’s a single let or an HMO. The ICR is a percentage of the expected monthly rental income, in relation to the so called “stressed” monthly interest payment, which considers likely future interest rate increases.

The ICR is used to measure affordability for a buy-to-let landlord and assess how easily a landlord will be able to pay interest payments as they fall due. In other words, whether the rental income to be earned from the property will be enough to support the monthly interest cost of the mortgage payments using an interest coverage ratio (ICR) test.

Mortgage lenders use the ratio to assess the resilience of the landlord’s portfolio to increases in interest rate.

But in my view, these rates are clearly over cautious and over the top.

It is not all the fault of lenders. It was the Prudential Regulatory Authority (PRA) of the Bank of England that issued rules for calculating the minimum ICR in September 2016 in Supervisory Statement SS13/16, called the Underwriting standards for buy-to let mortgage contracts.

The Standards state that lenders should consider rental demand and typical rent levels within the property’s locality, verified by an independent qualified valuer. The valuer should use “automated valuation models or evidence of an existing rental agreement, subject to appropriate policies, controls and risk management”.

But lenders have some flexibility in the data and information they choose to determine the minimum ICR threshold for a mortgage, including portfolio level data and data based on models.

The PRA advises that lenders should consider:

  • management and letting fees, council tax, service charge, insurance,
  • repairs
  • voids
  • utilities
  • gas and electrical certificates
  • licence fee
  • ground rent
  • any other costs associated with renting out the property irrespective of whether the borrower is an individual or a company.

Until 2017, lenders typically looked for a minimum ICR of 125% calculated using an appropriate stressed interest rate for buy to let landlords.

The stressed ICR of 125% reflects the amount of gross rental income required for landlords to break even, factoring in the costs of mortgage repayments (including a potential increase in interest rates), tax and property maintenance.

However, following the changes to Mortgage Interest Tax Relief (MITR), phased in between 2017 and 2020, (the infamous Section 24), individual landlords could no longer offset the full mortgage interest payments against their rental income for tax purposes. Instead, they were only permitted to a tax credit equal to 20% of their mortgage interest repayments.

This had the effect of increasing the tax bill for higher-rate taxpayers, and higher-rate taxpayers now need more rental income to breakeven.

This means that an acceptable stressed ICR for higher rate taxpayers is usually a whopping 145%, while additional rate taxpayers might be assessed at up to 165%.

The interest coverage ratio formula and percentage do however vary according to the lender, so shop around and bear in mind too, they may be stricter still if you have a larger portfolio.

It is insane. And I do believe it forms a key plank in what I call the “war on kulak landlords” that has been waged by the uniparty for years. (They just don’t like ordinary folk owning properties, they would rather it was all owned by big corporations who can be more easily controlled).

So, back to my property again, the property is worth around £430K, the highest mortgage amount I can get is around £160K, leaving the lender with £270K collateral if I ever default on their poxy mortgage. Where exactly is the risk in this for them?

A key take away is this. Sure, the mortgage rates look good today, and a lot less than they were in 2010, relative to base rates, but the constraints I have described here mean that landlords just cannot borrow to sensible levels.

Most lenders know this is very stupid, they know the regulatory rules and constraints are stupid, however, they still over-apply them in many cases. Most brokers know it is all stupid too, and they too find it very frustrating, not least as it cuts the income they can earn too.

It is all just a part of the war on small, independent landlords.

Unsurprisingly, the constraints on lending I have described here has led to a burgeoning private finance market, which has grown hugely in the last twenty years. Landlords, refurbers and developers meet people with cash to lend or who can provide equity at networking events all around the UK every week. I bet the government would like to stop that too!

Tell me about your experience.  

Services for Private Landlords and Organisations

We help landlords and property investors by showing them how to make money in the private rented sector using ways which are fair to tenants and which involve minimal risk. Our advice is completely independent.

We also advise a range of organisations too – public, charities and private – to help them develop and improve their services and products for private landlords.

HOME PAGE : Home – Letting Focus

For general information on our CONSULTING SERVICES: Consultancy and Seminars

For ONE-TO-ONE PRIVATE CONSULTANCY FOR PRIVATE LANDLORDS: Property Advice

IN THE MEDIA: Recent Press Coverage

BOOKS:

“SUCCESSFUL PROPERTY LETTING”:

Click here to Find Out More and Buy it. And if you are from an organisation and would like to bulk buy, please ask us for special rates.

“BUY TO LET LANDLORDS GUIDE TO FINDING GREAT TENANTS”:

Also, get this, which covers everything you’ll ever need to know to avoid either you or your letting agent getting anyone other than the perfect tenant. Click Here to Buy It.

BOOK FOR TENANTS:

Kids going off and renting for the first time? My Book for Tenants is also Available

TO JOIN OUR FREE NEWSLETTER MAILER which goes to over 3,960 people (as at December 2023) just send an email to david@LettingFocus.com

We do not send spam or sell our mailing list to advertisers, though we occasionally mail landlords about good products from third parties. Please put us on your “white-list” to ensure you receive our emails.

OFFERS ON PRODUCTS FOR LANDLORDS and TO ADVERTISE YOUR PRODUCTS to LANDLORDS: Landlords Resources

TWITTER / X:

Twitter banned me twice permanently for life. (I may be the only person that has ever happened to!?). After three years and two months, I finally got round to appealing again, hoping the new ownership would allow me back on. They did! So, I am back on and so are my 7,000 plus followers : Twitter 

2 comments

  • I use to work for a high street bank and when managing corporate property portfolio clients we too worked on LTVs of circa 70% and an interest coverage ratio ( or rental cover of repayment or interest payments ) of 125% irrespective of whether it was a limited company or other ownership structure. Occasionally, if the risk v reward judgement required it we would request 140%. I left that industry in 2013 so I don’t know what happens today, but my partner who’s a mortgage broker and former commercial property lender echoes the groans you have about the landlord’s tax status significantly impacting the ICR. She has come across many situations where a remortgaging landlord either needs to stump up more cash, or raise the rent to a much higher level to get a new mortgage deal, even at the same mortgage size. This clearly works against tenants as they would have to pay higher rents, and landlords losing some of their cash reserve for emergencies or simple diversification of their wealth. Mortgage lenders lose too as they will see their turn on the debt possibly reduce if the borrower pays down some debt. If this is a continuation of the war on landlords and private property, then govt’s, as it includes previous ones which didn’t change anything, are creating all sorts of incentives and trade offs that will result in unintended consequences that cut the govt’s revenues and which were not modelled nor expected by their PPE graduate advisors! It’s all reminiscent of the covid years when the idiotic and evidence free mantra “no one is safe until we’re all safe” took hold! Naturally, no one wants to have to bail out the lenders again, but I agree lenders are being nudged by regulators, read govt, to press for an almost risk free environment that just kills private enterprise and the market for debt, unless of course they only want folk to buy govt debt! Putting safety before freedom sounds kind and fluffy and morally right, but this isn’t the real world which we live in. We need risk to grow and develop just like an athlete needs resistance to build strength and agility. Keep up the great work pointing out the pincer movement against landlords, private enterprise and our cherished freedoms by sharing your excellent landlord observations.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.