Rent Controls Don’t Work (and Everyone Knows It) and the Creeping Nationalisation of the Private Rented Sector
In this piece, I look at rent controls and how the creeping nationalisation of the private rented sector is coming along.
Rent controls are likely to reduce the supply of housing for tenants and push some landlords to leave the market, this is the staggering conclusion of research from the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS).
It says that private renters spent an average 28% of their household incomes on housing costs in 2024–25, compared with just over 11% across households generally. Obviously, those percentages are much higher in London and some other big cities.
The IFS claims that evidence from countries including Ireland, Germany and parts of the US, shows controls can lower costs for tenants already living in affected properties, but can also produce unintended consequences.
You don’t say!
The authors say: “The evidence suggests that, unless UK housing markets differ substantially from those in the countries that have implemented them, rent controls would be a costly way to alleviate pressure on housing costs and support renters. Rent controls might partly achieve policymakers’ distributional aims by decreasing costs for some tenants and reducing tenants’ uncertainty over rents (at the expense of landlords). But the experience of other countries where controls have been introduced suggests other tenants would likely be made worse off by these controls, as more tenants struggle to find homes to meet their needs and the quality of rental homes declines. Lower-income and lower-wealth tenants with less scope to leave the private rented sector are likely to be particularly affected”.
Property quality will fall
The IFS says every study considered in a major 2024 evidence review found that rent controls reduced the supply of homes available to tenants, with some research also finding lower rates of housebuilding. Not only that but they cite evidence from New York which found a 36% increase in ‘immediately hazardous’ building code violations following the introduction of controls.
The report says landlords facing restrictions on rent increases may respond by cutting renovation or maintenance spending where there are still plenty of prospective tenants.
Yep, and that is why the stock of private rented property collapsed post WW2 – and the quality collapsed too – leading to the emergence of highly aggressive landlords like Peter Rachman.
Controls can also make it harder for households to move, with tenants remaining in homes that no longer meet their needs because suitable alternatives are difficult to find.
The IFS also points to Germany, where controls introduced in 2015 ultimately had no effect on average rents after about a year because of the way exemptions operated.
They also looked at research from Norwegian capital Oslo where they found that some landlords sought other forms of compensation, including extra services from tenants or deposits worth 10 or even 20 months of rent, requirements which largely disappeared after controls were removed.
You can see the report here. It argues that increasing the overall supply of housing through investment or planning reform would tackle the underlying pressure on housing costs more directly.
It also says tax and benefit policy could target financial help more closely at lower-income tenants rather than giving the largest benefit to people who already occupy rent-controlled homes.
You don’t say!
Why do we have to re-learn things that have been established over hundreds of years and in different places?:
RENT CONTROLS DO NOT WORK. They only work in the heads of economically illiterate clowns like the current Green leader, Mr. Polanski, who sees a way to convince other dumb people to vote for him, people who presumably also fail to think things through.
Nationalisation by Stealth and by a Thousand Cuts
The Renters’ Rights Act 2025 is a clever piece of legislation perfectly designed to strip away the practical benefits of property ownership while leaving landlords carrying the capital, maintenance, regulatory and other risks. The underlying mechanisms of it can be slowly applied through secondary legislation, enforcement policy and tribunal decisions, enabling the government to test how much further value control can be transferred before the market reaches breaking point.
At that point, property values will be so depressed that government—or public bodies acting with government support such as housing associations —may then acquire properties compulsorily, financed through publicly backed housing bonds. Private landlords who would have carried the risks and absorbed the losses will lose completely; the state would acquire the assets at diminished values and, through taxation and public borrowing. This is not another cycle of housing regulation. It represents a wholesale ideological transformation of the property market.
Interestingly, Mr Bumham has another card to play – and we are sure it will be played in October in the budget.
This involves raising capital gains tax rates to align with income tax rates. So, most landlords will see their CGT rate hiked to 40 or 50%. This will make more of them stay in the market than would otherwise happen – after all, for many it will be the same as the IHT rate of 40%. This means a little bit of the private rented sector can be kept alive – whilst it still has some uses – and before the full and effective nationalisation of the private rented sector is complete.
Services for Private Landlords and Organisations
We help landlords and property investors by showing them how to make money in the private rented sector using ways which are fair to tenants and which involve minimal risk. Our advice is completely independent.
We also advise a range of organisations too – public, charities and private – to help them develop and improve their services and products for private landlords.
HOME PAGE : Home – Letting Focus
For general information on our CONSULTING SERVICES: Consultancy and Seminars
For ONE-TO-ONE PRIVATE CONSULTANCY FOR PRIVATE LANDLORDS: Property Advice
IN THE MEDIA: Recent Press Coverage
BOOKS:
“SUCCESSFUL PROPERTY LETTING”:
Click here to Find Out More and Buy it. And if you are from an organisation and would like to bulk buy, please ask us for special rates.
“BUY TO LET LANDLORDS GUIDE TO FINDING GREAT TENANTS”:
Also, get this, which covers everything you’ll ever need to know to avoid either you or your letting agent getting anyone other than the perfect tenant. Click Here to Buy It.
BOOK FOR TENANTS:
Kids going off and renting for the first time? My Book for Tenants is also Available
TO JOIN OUR FREE NEWSLETTER MAILER which goes to over 3,960 people (as at December 2023) just send an email to david@LettingFocus.com
We do not send spam or sell our mailing list to advertisers, though we occasionally mail landlords about good products from third parties. Please put us on your “white-list” to ensure you receive our emails.
OFFERS ON PRODUCTS FOR LANDLORDS and TO ADVERTISE YOUR PRODUCTS to LANDLORDS: Landlords Resources
.