Scullion Case v Bank of Scotland Decision Seems Wrong and the Implications for Landlords
“Every buy to let landlord is sophisticated and needs no protection. Caveat Emptor.”
That would seem to be the message coming out of a recent court judgement
You may have heard of the Scullion case. If not, I’ll remind you as it’s pretty interesting and relevant for anyone buying property to let now or who has bought in the past.
In 2002, a Mr. Scullion bought a flat to let in Cobham, Surrey – a very nice part of the world indeed, where I have spent many happy hours with good friends we know who live there.
On his application he said he thought the property was worth £353K and he applied for a buy to let mortgage of £283K. The lenders instructed a surveyors firm to do the valuation. They valued the property at £353K and with a rental income of £2,000 per month and a mortgage was duly approved.
The transaction went ahead, (though Mr Scullion paid less than the £353K), but Mr Scullion found that, try as he might, he could not achieve more than £1100 in rent (just over half of what the valuer had predicted), which as it was more than the mortgage payments, made the property unviable. He decided to sell.
Capital Loss
Things got worse when he came to try to sell the property, as he found the best price he could achieve was again a lot less than the valuation – and he ended up selling the property for just £250K, incurring a capital loss.
Mr Scullion made a claim in court against the valuer for losses he says he incurred as a result of their negligence and at a first trial, the judge agreed with him, found the valuer negligent and awarded £72K to Mr Scullion.
Worried about an avalanche of similar claims, RICS did what most big institutions and companies do in these circumstances – they appealed to a higher court, thus raising the stakes (and no doubt the costs) for Mr. Scullion. Nevertheless, Mr Scullion, who must be made of stern stuff, fought on.
Court of Appeal Findings
However, at the Court of Appeal the judge decided that this was a “commercial transaction,” that people investing in let property were usually richer, were more likely to have multiple properties and were more “commercially astute.” As such, he implies that unlike someone buying a property to live in for themselves, they ought to be expected to do their own due diligence and, if necessary, obtain their own survey on rental valuation and capital value.
Also, the judge said, the lender was really only interested in the capital value of the property and any advice on rental value would be provided simply to confirm the property was suitable for rental purposes.
In summary, the decision was that the surveyor who provides a valuation to a lender does not owe a duty of care to a borrower who is seeking funds to buy a property for investment purposes.
More Appeals
I read that Mr Scullion’s solicitors look set to obtain permission to appeal to the Supreme Court on the argument that the duty of care should still be owed to small buy to let investors who, they will no doubt argue, could not be labelled as sophisticated investors.
I agree they should not be classified as sophisticated investors – and here’s why.
In the past I used to attend and sometimes speak at various property shows. Particularly in the period from 1998 to 2005 I saw many very novice investors being persuaded by what can best be described as “Snake Oil Salesmen in Suits” to buy new build inner city flats that I always thought were seriously overvalued on both capital value and rental income.
All too often these investors had the same experience as Mr Scullion. They suffered big losses.
I know that many of the “investors” were not experienced people at all because I have met quite a few.
Many were rather taken in by glib sales patter, hoping that they could become property millionaires in double quick time.
These “investors” might have expected the valuer to protect them from their folly but they were failed by the valuers too.
Foxtons Case Precedent?
In the case involving Foxtons and their unfair hidden repeat renewal fees charged to landlords, the judge said the hidden terms in Foxtons (and some other letting agents’ contracts) amounted to a trap for landlords.
He decided that, the smaller landlords were not sophisticated business people who might be expected to read all the small print and that they were due protection under the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts laws. He was right.
Foxtons fought the case for a long time, just like RICS are doing now.
But in the end it was Foxtons who lost. We think Mr Scullion’s people have a valid case too.
In the meantime the judgment means that private landlords should make sure they do their due diligence and not rely on valuers’ estimates of rental potential.
Mortgage lenders will meanwhile presumably continue to reach agreements on liability with valuers where the lender had to take the hit on losses following repossessions of let property which had been overvalued by valuers and which could not be recovered from a landlord.
MORE ABOUT LETTINGFOCUS AND WHAT WE DO
LettingFocus.com is the home of Private Rented Sector Expertise and advice.
Services to Businesses and the Public Sector
We are consultants to a range of organisations including viagra online 100 mg banks, building societies, local authorities, social housing providers, institutional investors and insurers. We help them develop and improve their services and products for private landlords.
We also write for property websites, speak at property shows and we are regularly quoted by the media.
Services for Private Landlords
We also find a limited amount of time to help landlords and property investors by coaching them in how to make money in the private rented sector using ways that work, which are ethical, fair to tenants and which involve minimal risk to the investor.
AT OUR WEBSITE LETTINGFOCUS.COM:
HOME PAGE OF THIS BLOG click here: Blog
To read blog posts on related posts use the tags and categories at the bottom of each post (after the list of links), or over to the top right. Here, you can click on “Select Categories” and use the pull down menu to read all the posts on any Category that interests you.
THE HOME PAGE OF OUR MAIN SITE : http://www.LettingFocus.com
For general info on our CONSULTING SERVICES and also to find a small sample of links to where our comments have been featured in the National Press please click here: Consultancy and Seminars
For ONE TO ONE PRIVATE CONSULTANCY FOR PRIVATE LANDLORDS click here: Property Advice
TO READ CLIENT TESTIMONIALS – from both organisations and private landlords click here: Testimonials
BUY “SUCCESSFUL PROPERTY LETTING”
Our book is the highest selling property book in the UK. Click here to Find Out More and Buy the Book at Amazon. If you are from an organisation and would like to bulk buy at least 50 books please ask us for special rates.
To JOIN our Free NEWSLETTER which goes to 2,000 people and contains regular news for landlords and details of our Events simply send an email to david@LettingFocus.com – Please note we WILL NOT send spam or sell our mailing list to advertisers but please put us on your “white list” to ensure you receive our emails.
Discounted Products for Landlords: Landlords Resources
This blog is updated once a week, usually on a Monday or Tuesday (or more frequently when “hot” news items come up.)
For my random thoughts on property and personal finance, plus other random things that interest me from sports, to 80s and 90s Indy music, to tsunamis, to politics please see our TWITTER PAGE: Twitter
Copyright of Blog: David Lawrenson 2011. Link to us or Quote us.
We actively pursue any copyright infringements.
LINK TO THIS BLOG OR TO OUR WEBSITE